Why are semiconductor factories so expensive?
Modern gigafabs cost five to 20 billion dollars - because the visible cleanroom is just the tip of the iceberg.
A simple workshop for a metal construction company with a few milling machines and a CNC center may be available for as little as a quarter to half a million euros. For a new car factory, investments of around 100 million euros are typical. Today, however, a new gigafab-class chip plant can quickly cost the equivalent of five, ten or even 20 billion dollars.
Where do these glaring differences come from?
"The clean room that you see in many pictures of chip factories is really just the tip of the iceberg," explains Marek Jakowatz, the commercial manager of the new Bosch factory in Dresden, who was also responsible for global supply logistics in the Bosch Group for many years. "You don't even see the other 90 percent, who make sure that all' the equipment works at all." And from GlobalFoundries Dresden, "The basic infrastructure, the 'basebuild,' requires many times the amount of additional plant technology, most of which is densely packed and distributed on a size of several soccer fields directly below the clean room."
Infrastructure/subfab" cost factor
This refers, for example, to elaborate piping systems and tanks for process gases, ultra-pure water, silicon wafers, spare parts stores, control electronics, redundant power lines, refrigeration systems, filter systems for the cleanroom atmosphere and more. A significant part of these infrastructures is located in the "subfab", invisible to visitors, a huge automated and mostly deserted supply factory below the actual manufacturing level that keeps chip production running.
Cost factor "vibration-free clean room
The above-average capital expenditure for modern chip fabs begins in the shell construction phase: Because even the small vibrations of a truck whizzing by on the neighboring street or a pump in the subfab would upset the sensitive exposure systems and cause expensive rejects, the cleanroom production levels of a chip fab must be vibration-free. Often, designers solve the problem by anchoring the lowest fab level to an underground slab of natural rock with piles dozens of feet long. The clean room is then decoupled from the rest of the building by small joints and strong springs. These and other precautions drive up the consumption of concrete, steel and other materials in the construction of a chip factory.
Cost factor "column-free cleanroom
Additional construction costs are incurred due to the desire to make maximum use of the space in the cleanroom, which is supplied at great expense. This leads to a column-free design. This requires special design precautions that are far more elaborate than in a column-supplied workshop.
Cost factor "plant park
A significant cost driver is the lithography equipment, vacuum chambers, dry etching, implantation and drying units, as well as many other high-tech systems required for the core process steps ("front end") of semiconductor manufacturing. These systems ("tools") belong to high technology and are correspondingly expensive. To manufacture a wafer, many such semiconductor tools are needed. Some of them cost "only" half a million euros, but others cost 15 million euros or more. If, for example, a fab uses lithography with extreme ultraviolet light (EUV), it can cost up to 120 million euros per system. To this must be added the costs for the mask sets, i.e. the exposure templates for each individual chip.
Cost factor "automation"
Due to the complexity of the process, but also in view of the fierce international competitive pressure, chip factories today are built highly automated right from the start so that personnel costs - especially in high-wage countries - do not become too significant. A certain degree of automation is relatively easy to achieve and is often already included in the equipment purchased. However, the closer this level of automation approaches the 100 percent mark, the more technologically complicated and expensive each additional percentage point becomes.
Cost factor "high-purity media"
For chip production, microelectronics companies need specially processed and extremely pure gases and chemicals as well as sometimes quite expensive special auxiliary materials. These include noble gases, hydrogen, oxygen, but also aqua regia, ultrapure water and wafers made of ultrapure silicon.
Cost factor energy and water
Chip factories are major consumers of electricity, heat, water and cooling. Bosch's Dresden chip factory, for example, requires as much electricity as an entire small town with around 30,000 inhabitants. GlobalFoundries' Fab 1 needs around half a terawatt hour of electrical energy per year and as much thermal energy again.
The energy and material flows required for ongoing operation are usually routed redundantly to avoid a production stoppage under all circumstances. If the equipment in a chip factory suddenly comes to a standstill due to a power outage or a missing process gas, this not only results in millions of euros worth of scrap, but it can also take weeks or even months to start up and restart the equipment. GlobalFoundries Dresden has therefore built two small power plants of its own to provide additional backup. All these additional lines, buffers and reserves naturally cause extra costs.
End of the cost spiral is not in sight
With each new chip fab generation, the capital expenditure increases very significantly. As recently as the mid-1990s, costs of the equivalent of about 1.5 billion euros per fab were common. Today's top fabs from TSMC, Samsung or Intel cost the equivalent of five to 20 billion euros. And this trend is likely to continue. "Ever more powerful semiconductor chips require ever more complex and therefore more expensive technologies," explains Dresden-based GlobalFoundries spokeswoman Karin Raths. "The rule of thumb here is that the smaller the structure sizes, the more a fab costs, as the machines and processes become even more complex and precise and also require more lithography masks."
This article was first published as part of our NEXT magazine "In the spotlight: Microelectronics".